NBC Universal, unable to come to an agreement with Apple on pricing, has decided not to renew its contract to sell digital downloads of television shows on iTunes.
The media conglomerate — which is the No. 1 supplier of digital video
to Apple’s online store, accounting for about 40 percent of downloads —
notified Apple of its decision late yesterday, according to a person
familiar with the matter who asked for anonymity because negotiations
between the companies are confidential.
A spokesman for NBC Universal, part of General Electric,
confirmed the decision, but otherwise declined to comment. A spokesmen
for Apple declined to comment. The decision by NBC Universal highlights
the escalating tension between Apple and media companies, which are
unhappy that Apple will not give them more control over the pricing of
songs and videos that are sold on iTunes.
NBC Universal is also
seeking better piracy controls and wants Apple to allow it to bundle
videos to increase revenue, the person familiar with the matter said.
NBC
Universal is the second major iTunes supplier recently to have a rift
with Apple over pricing and packaging matters. In July, the Universal
Music Group of Vivendi, the world’s biggest music corporation, said it
would not renew its long-term contract with iTunes. Instead, Universal
Music said it would market music to Apple at will, which would allow it
to remove its songs from iTunes on short notice.
The action by Jeff Zucker,
NBC Universal’s chief executive, will not have an immediate impact on
iTunes. The current two-year deal extends through December, so a vast
video catalog — some 1,500 hours of NBC Universal’s news, sports and
entertainment programming — will remain available on iTunes at least
until then.
Among the most popular NBC Universal shows available
for sale on iTunes are “Battlestar Galactica,” “The Office” and
“Heroes.” The company has been talking to iTunes about offering
Universal movies, but has not done so to date because of piracy
concerns.
The two companies could still reach an agreement on a
new contract before their current deal expires. While each side has so
far refused to budge, the talks will continue and have been free of
acrimony, the person familiar with the matter said.
But the
defiant moves by NBC Universal and Universal Music could embolden other
media companies that have been less than thrilled with Apple’s
policies. NBC Universal was the second company to sign an agreement
with Apple to sell content on iTunes, and its contract stipulated that
Apple receive notice of plans to cancel 90 days before the expiration
date. Otherwise, the deal would automatically renew according to the
original terms.
Assuming similar provisions in deals negotiated with media companies like CBS, Discovery and the News Corporation, a parade of 90-day windows will be coming due.
A
move by NBC Universal to walk away or withdraw a large amount of
content would probably hobble Apple’s efforts to move deeper into the
sale of video-focused consumer electronics like the iPhone
and a new class of iPods. While Apple’s early efforts in this area
depended on music to fuel sales, analysts say video is what will drive
much of Apple’s retail business in the future.
The iTunes
service wields incredible power in the music business, since it
accounts for more than 76 percent of digital music sales. And its
influence is on the rise: Apple recently passed Amazon to become the third-biggest seller of music over all, behind Wal-Mart and Best Buy, according to the market research firm NPD.
But
the sale of video online is still at a nascent stage. Media giants like
NBC Universal are aggressively trying to move into the business — in
part to avoid the piracy that has plagued music companies — but the
revenue they earn from online video sales does not yet have a material
impact on their financial performances.
So some media companies
feel they have the upper hand: Apple, for now at least, needs their
content more than they need Apple. And there are an array of companies
— like Amazon, Wal-Mart, Microsoft and Sony — that would love to have NBC Universal as a partner to muscle in on Apple’s turf.
Then there is NBC Universal’s own Hulu.com, a venture in partnership with the News Corporation to build a video portal to compete with YouTube.
The
risks that media companies face in removing content from well-known Web
sites involve perception and promotion. NBC Universal could anger
consumers by preventing them from easily watching shows and movies in
the most popular way — through iTunes and the iPod.
Television networks and movie studios have vigorously tried to avoid
being branded with the same anticonsumer sentiment that has worked
against the record labels.
And because iTunes is so popular, NBC
Universal would lose an increasingly important way of marketing
entertainment products, particularly fledgling television shows, to
consumers.
For months, most media companies have grumbled that
Apple underprices video and audio content as a way to propel sales of a
much more significant profit center: iPods and related merchandise.
(One noteworthy abstainer from the grumbling is the Walt Disney Company, which has Apple’s chief executive, Steven P. Jobs, as a board member.)
The
iTunes service has sold songs for 99 cents each since its beginning
four years ago, except for the recent introduction of songs without
copy protection. Episodes of television shows sell for $1.99, with
movies priced at $9.99.
NBC Universal and other companies say
they want to increase prices by packaging content— say an episode of
“The Office” with the movie “The 40- Year-Old Virgin,” because they
both star the comedian Steve Carell.
In the past, Apple has argued that a range of pricing would complicate the iTunes experience and squelch demand.